The South Shore Press
← Back to Local
Local

Brookhaven Planning Board Schedules Nine Hearings for Thursday

The 3 p.m. session at Town Hall includes a Life Time Fitness club in East Setauket, a Starbucks with a drive-through in Middle Island and a mixed retail and office building in Bellport.

By The South Shore Press
Brookhaven Planning Board Schedules Nine Hearings for Thursday
A former stretch of New York State Route 25 at Picasso Way in Middle Island, New York, in a file photograph from November 15, 2014.Credit: DanTD / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The Brookhaven Planning Board is scheduled to hold nine public hearings Thursday, Nov. 19, beginning at 3 p.m. at Town Hall in Farmingville. The docket, posted on the Town Board agenda and on the town's public notices page, includes a Life Time Fitness club in East Setauket, a Starbucks with a drive-through in Middle Island and a two-story retail and office building in Bellport.

The Town Board is scheduled to convene at 5 p.m. the same day, with general public comment also listed for 5 p.m. None of the Planning Board applications has been decided. Staff reports in the meeting packet are advisory, and recommended conditions can change at the hearing.

At 384 Mark Tree Road in East Setauket, the applicant has applied for site-plan approval to tear down the existing fitness center and build a two-story health club of 94,000 square feet. The plan also includes outdoor recreation space, a parking deck of 57,000 square feet over a ground-level lot, and a pool deck of 42,000 square feet. Planning staff wrote that the 9.511-acre site shows 593 parking stalls, compared with 658 required for the building, and no loading stalls, compared with four required. The staff report says the Board of Zoning Appeals granted variances for setbacks, signs and light-pole height on April 29, 2026, and that the Three Village Civic Association was contacted and supports the project.

A companion hearing asks the Planning Board to lift covenants tied to the November 2005 World Gym approval, which reserved the board's power to address parking shortfalls and noise or vibration from a co-generation plant. Staff recommended dropping those covenants because World Gym would no longer operate at the site, and noted that the board can seek new covenants when it reviews the Life Time plan.

In Middle Island, RA Middle Island LLC wants approval of a site plan to convert a vacant bank building at 599 Middle Country Road into a Starbucks with a drive-through, outdoor seating and retail sales. The staff report lists 40 parking spaces proposed and 62 required, and no loading space where one is required. The Town Board approved a rezoning of the parcel from J Business 4 to J Business 5 on Oct. 23, 2025, and the new zoning took effect Jan. 5, 2026. The staff report places the site in the Central Pine Barrens compatible growth area.

The Bellport Center application, where Montauk Highway meets Station Road, at the southwest corner, would replace an office building on 0.51 acre with a two-story building containing 3,575 square feet of retail, 3,575 square feet of offices and a 3,559-square-foot basement. The plan shows 29 parking spaces, compared with 51 required under the staff report's parking calculation, and seeks a special permit for uses in a designated redevelopment initiative.

A separate Bellport application, listed as Queens Concrete and sited north of Horseblock Road and 570 feet east of County Road 101, seeks approval for a warehouse totaling 21,100 square feet, including 10,000 square feet of open-air space, with 40 parking spaces proposed and 54 required.

In Medford, Elite Towers is seeking approval for a 150-foot cellular communications tower at Country Farms, 200 Bellport Ave. Staff recommended conditions that include approval of plans last revised May 19, 2026, a highway work permit for any work in the road right-of-way, and a ban on clearing or other construction until a building permit is issued.

Three other hearings seek relief from restrictive covenants at 50 Timber Ridge Drive in Coram, 32 4th Ave. in Rocky Point and 64 Coram Swezeytown Road in Middle Island.

Residents can speak at the 3 p.m. hearings Thursday, before the board acts on any of the applications. Questions about the notices can be directed to the town's One Call line, 631-451-8696.

You Might Also Be Interested In