The South Shore Press
← Back to Local
Local

Police Seek Woman in September Theft at Centereach Target

Suffolk County Police and Crime Stoppers asked for help identifying a woman they said stole cosmetics and cookware from the Target at 265 Pond Path on Sept. 25. Department alerts show earlier theft reports at that address this year.

By The South Shore Press
Police Seek Woman in September Theft at Centereach Target
Suffolk County police released this surveillance image seeking to identify the woman shown.Credit: Suffolk County Police Department

Suffolk County Police and Suffolk County Crime Stoppers are asking the public to help identify a woman who police said stole merchandise from the Target store on Pond Path in Centereach in September.

Police said the woman took cosmetics and cookware from the Target at 265 Pond Path at 9:54 a.m. on Sept. 25. The department issued the alert on Thursday, Nov. 19, under the heading "Wanted for Centereach Petit Larceny," along with a surveillance photograph of the woman. The alert assigned the case to the Sixth Precinct Crime Section. It did not name the woman, give a written description of her or put a value on the merchandise.

The alert lists Sgt. Owen O'Callaghan as the authority and carries case numbers CW 26-245 and CC 26C0639078. Officers have not said whether they believe the woman is connected to any other case.

The store has appeared in Suffolk County Police alerts several times in 2026. A review of the department's published crime alerts found at least five earlier requests for help in thefts at 265 Pond Path since May. According to those alerts, a man stole toys from the store on May 14, a woman took health and beauty items on June 11, a man and a woman stole beauty products on Aug. 1, and two separate men stole merchandise on Sept. 1, one at about 9 a.m. and another at about 1:10 p.m. Police said the second man on Sept. 1 left in a white SUV. One of the Sept. 1 alerts identified the location as South Setauket, though it gave the same Pond Path address. The May 14 alert names Sixth Precinct officers in its text and lists the Fourth Precinct Crime Section as the authority. The later alerts list the Sixth Precinct Crime Section.

No one has been charged in the Sept. 25 theft.

The Sixth Precinct covers hamlets and incorporated villages in the northern part of the Town of Brookhaven, according to the department. Its commanding officer is Inspector Paul Mamay.

Crime Stoppers of Suffolk County, a not-for-profit organization created in 1994, pays cash rewards for tips that lead to an arrest, according to the organization. It says its rewards are paid from donations, with no taxpayer funds used, and that tipsters are known only by a code number, including when they collect a reward. The Nov. 19 alert said a cash reward is available if a tip leads to an arrest.

"Anyone with information about these incidents can contact Suffolk County Crime Stoppers to submit an anonymous tip by calling 1-800-220-TIPS, utilizing a mobile app which can be downloaded through the App Store or Google Play by searching P3 Tips, or online at www.P3Tips.com. All calls, text messages and emails will be kept confidential."

The Nov. 19 alert is a request for help identifying the woman police said took the merchandise on Sept. 25. No one has been charged in that theft. The case remains with the Sixth Precinct Crime Section.

You Might Also Be Interested In