Riverhead Investigates Suspected Tampering After Large Propane Tanks Leak
Brookhaven's supervisor says early findings point to deliberate acts. Neither town has announced a suspect or an arrest.

Fire marshals from Riverhead and Brookhaven stopped leaks Monday on multiple large propane tanks on Kroemer Avenue in Riverhead, and Dan Panico, Brookhaven's town supervisor, said early findings indicated the leaks were intentional.
"Early findings indicated that the leaks resulted from deliberate, malicious acts by an unknown person or persons," Panico said. Riverhead's town police and its fire marshal's office are handling the investigation, he said. As of Tuesday evening, neither town had named a suspect or announced an arrest.
According to a Town of Riverhead news release issued Nov. 17, Riverhead's fire and police departments went to Kroemer Avenue at about 5 p.m. Monday after a report of propane escaping. The fire department asked the town fire marshal's office for a hazardous materials response. Jordan Palmer and William Burns, both fire marshals, deployed the town's hazardous materials trailer, which the release says carries gear built to contain leaks of liquefied petroleum gas.
Panico said Riverhead's chief fire marshal asked Brookhaven for help at 5:15 p.m. The request described a hazardous materials incident near Old Country Road, he said, involving multiple tanks of 500 and 1,000 gallons that were actively leaking. Brookhaven's evening-shift fire marshal went first. A second marshal and a senior marshal followed, bringing Brookhaven's hazardous materials unit. Panico said the Brookhaven team worked alongside a Riverhead fire marshal and the Riverhead Fire Department, stopped each leak and made the scene safe. Brookhaven's units left at 9:20 p.m., he said.
"Brookhaven and Riverhead worked together to prevent what could have been a massive explosion," Panico said.
The Riverhead release says Jamesport firefighters stood by at the Riverhead department's headquarters and that the county's fire, rescue and emergency services department responded to help with coordination. The road was closed "to protect public safety and determine the cause and extent of the leak," the release says, and reopened at about 7 p.m. It adds that responders identified and contained the source.
Propane gas is 1.55 times as dense as air, according to the federal National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, and it can ignite at concentrations of 2.1 to 9.5 percent in air.
Riverhead Chief Fire Marshal Andrew Smith, quoted in the release, credited the first responders. "We are very grateful for the rapid response of the Riverhead Fire Department and our own fire marshal's office. The outcome may have been different if it hadn't been for the training and expertise of our first responders," Smith said.
The response came three months after the Riverhead Town Board voted 5 to 0 on Aug. 18 to establish a town hazardous materials response team and adopt a written emergency response plan. A version of the plan dated April 1, 2026, which the board saw in May, makes the town fire marshal's office the lead agency on hazardous materials calls that involve no fire or medical emergency. It classifies the new team as Type III with some Type II capabilities and lists Brookhaven and Southampton teams as regional partners under intermunicipal agreements. At a May work session, an official presenting the plan told the board that the county had surplused trailers for the team. A Suffolk County resolution dated Dec. 16, 2025, directed the county fire and emergency services department to transfer surplus trailers to Riverhead, Brookhaven and Babylon.
Town Supervisor Jerry Halpin, quoted in the release, linked Monday's outcome to that effort. "Incidents like this magnify the importance of having a fully operational hazardous material response team in the Town of Riverhead and we are lucky to have Fire Marshal Smith at the helm," Halpin said.
For background, news reports from 2021 and 2022 describe a separate project on the same street. The Riverhead Planning Board gave final site plan approval in 2022 to 48 Kroemer LLC for a propane distribution facility with six 30,000-gallon tanks, or 180,000 gallons, beside an existing propane facility. Officials have not said where the leaking tanks are in relation to that site, and the reports reviewed do not show whether it has been built. No official has linked that project, or any company, to Monday's leaks, and the statements released so far do not say who owns the damaged tanks.
Each leak was stopped Monday, Panico said. The investigation by Riverhead police and the town fire marshal's office continues, and officials have not said when they will share findings on who caused the leaks or why.
You Might Also Be Interested In

Tuttle Avenue School Joins 321 Kindness Links Into One Schoolwide Chain

Illegal Immigrant Pleads Guilty to Raping 12-Year-Old

Brookhaven Library Gets Its Thanksgiving Groove On


