The South Shore Press
← Back to Local
Local

Suffolk County Closes on 49-Acre St. Johnland Property in Kings Park

Romaine Says Land to Be Added to Parks Inventory

By The South Shore Press
Suffolk County Closes on 49-Acre St. Johnland Property in Kings Park
The main entrance to the St. Johnland Nursing Center in Kings Park in a file photograph from October 24, 2018.Credit: DanTD / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

County Executive Ed Romaine said Tuesday, with Legislator Sal Formica, that Suffolk County has completed a closing on 49 acres at the St. Johnland site, south of Sunken Meadow Road in Kings Park, in the Town of Smithtown. The county put the sale price at $8.8 million and said the land includes seven acres it called critical wetland, inside the state's Recreational River Corridor for the Nissequogue.

Romaine said the county used $5 million in state funding toward the purchase. "This is an exceedingly rare opportunity In western Suffolk County to preserve open space and add environmentally sensitive land to our park’s system inventory," he said in the announcement. "We leveraged $5 million of state funding to make this purchase possible while securing the entire 49-acre parcel for future generations to enjoy." Formica, of the 13th Legislative District, which includes Kings Park, said the land "will now remain protected for the wildlife and the environment" and that "open space preservation will continue to be a top priority of mine." The county said its economic development and planning department pointed to wetlands and hydric soils on the site, and to nearby land that is environmentally sensitive, as grounds for buying the property. The Parks Department, the announcement said, recommended the purchase.

Procedural Resolution No. 50-2026, laid on the table Sept. 9, names the Society of St. Johnland as the reputed owner of a 49.01-acre parcel, more or less, on the south side of Sunken Meadow Road, tax map District 0800, Section 008.00, Block 04.00, Lot 002.003. County tax parcel owner records, retrieved on Nov. 18, list that 49.011-acre parcel under the same name. The New York Department of State lists the Society of St. Johnland as a New York nonprofit corporation, Department of State ID 10379, first filed May 20, 1870, in Suffolk. St. Johnland Nursing Center Inc. is listed as the owner of other lots on the campus, but not of this parcel. A recorded County Clerk deed for the closing was not located in the free public materials reviewed on Nov. 18. A review of the Legislature's posted October and mid-November meeting files found no separate acquisition or closing resolution for the parcel.

The society's federal Form 990 for the year that ended Dec. 31, 2025, posted as filed Sept. 23, 2026, lists David H. Deming as president, Michael A. Agnes as treasurer and Arlene Q. Vermylen as secretary. The unpaid board members named on that return are Heather L. Spehr, Dr. Marian Conway, Frank J. Sparacino Jr., William J. Mich Jr. and Joan Shilling. Michael Tretola is listed as chief executive officer and Joseph Santangelo as chief financial officer, with pay from a related organization.

A search of state Board of Elections contribution records from 1999 forward listed no contributions in the name of the Society of St. Johnland or St. Johnland Nursing Center Inc. A search of Federal Election Commission records listed no contributions in the society's name. A search of state lobbyist registrations from 2019 forward, and of the county's registered lobbyists list, found no entry for the society, Deming or Tretola.

A historic marker at 395 Sunken Meadow Road, placed in 2020 with a grant to the Town of Smithtown and sponsored by the William G. Pomeroy Foundation, records that the Rev. William Augustus Muhlenberg established the St. Johnland Society there in 1866 to serve orphaned and poor residents.

The county says it has closed on the parcel and, in Romaine's words, added the land to its parks inventory. The Nov. 17 announcement names no opening date or planned facilities, and any public access remains for the county to announce.

You Might Also Be Interested In