The South Shore Press
← Back to Opinion
Opinion

Parliament Should Strike 'Grossly Offensive' From the Speech Law

A retired policeman is waiting on an appeal after being convicted over a bacon meme about Islam. John Cleese posted a similar joke to five million followers, and no criminal charge against him has been reported. The appeal ruling is due in December.

By Howard Roark
Parliament Should Strike 'Grossly Offensive' From the Speech Law
John Cleese speaks at Comiccon Open Air in Vilvoorde, Belgium, on July 4, 2026.Credit: Miguel Discart & Kiri Karma / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

On Nov. 13, John Cleese posted a pun on X. "Why don't Muslim women smoke pot ?" the Monty Python veteran asked his five million followers. "It's because they don't enjoy getting stoned." He closed with "Any others ?" and the replies obliged. By Monday morning that post had more than 1.2 million views. Two days later Cleese summed himself up as "Just an old pro-Free Speech, anti-child marriage bigot."

That same Friday, a retired policeman named Stephen Gray stood in Teesside Crown Court asking a judge to wipe out a criminal conviction. His offence was a Facebook repost. The meme read: "Fun facts about Bacon! People who eat bacon have a lower chance of marrying a nine-year-old!" Gray, 65, served 27 years with Cleveland Police. He told the court his Facebook audience is about 15 or 20 people.

Set the two men side by side and British speech law starts to resemble a lottery. Both jokes take aim at Islam. Gray's meme points at the Hadith account of the Prophet's marriage to Aisha, an account his own barrister recited in open court, and Cleese's self-description puts child marriage at the center of his complaint too. Cleese's run of posts, one of which has reached more than a million screens, drew a referral to a government counter-extremism scheme, while a meme seen by perhaps 20 people produced a criminal record.

A next-door neighbour, someone Gray says he was already feuding with, took the bacon post to police. The group now paying for his appeal, and a contemporaneous account of the magistrates' case, say Crown prosecutors first declined to charge him, finding no realistic prospect of a conviction, then reversed that decision after the neighbour used a formal right that lets a victim ask for that choice to be reviewed. Gray was convicted under section 127, a 2003 Communications Act provision that makes it a crime to send a "grossly offensive" message over a public network. The statute allows up to six months in prison. In April, a district judge in Newton Aycliffe convicted him. The fines and costs he was told to pay topped £1,000.

Those same accounts say he had been charged over two reposts. One mocked asylum hotels and called for mass deportation, and, they say, the judge did not treat it as grossly offensive because immigration is a political subject Parliament itself debates. The bacon meme, on their account, was ruled to be about religion, and grossly offensive. If that is what happened in the magistrates' court, a joke about immigration was treated as political speech and a joke about a religious founder was treated as a crime. England and Wales abolished common-law blasphemy, and blasphemous libel, by statute in 2008. A vague phrase in a telecoms law now appears to do the same work, and this conviction concerned a joke about one faith.

Cleese has met a milder official response. A member of the public filed a referral to Prevent, the government's counter-extremism programme, on Sept. 22, accusing him of a long run of anti-Muslim posts. Cleese responded to the referral with mock enthusiasm and has described himself as Islamosceptic. He has compared his jokes about Islam to the jokes he and his colleagues made about Christianity in "Life of Brian." No public report of an arrest or a criminal charge arising from the referral has appeared.

Cleese should never be prosecuted for his jokes. Many readers will find them tasteless, and he plainly enjoys that. A free country lets him be tasteless, and Gray deserved the same latitude when he shared his meme. The jokes are close enough in content that the gap in outcomes points elsewhere. It is easier to bring a charge against a pensioner with a hostile neighbour and about 20 online friends than against a performer with millions of followers.

At the appeal, Gray said he shared the meme "To bring to light what is not a very nice part of what goes on in this country - child marriage, forced marriage and just the way some children are treated." His barrister, John Beggs KC, put the principle more bluntly: "we are entitled to be offensive in this country."

Bryan Cox, the recorder, heard the case with two magistrates and set a December date to deliver the result. A win for Gray would clear this conviction and leave section 127 unchanged. The lasting fix belongs to Parliament, which can strike the words "grossly offensive" from the statute and require prosecutors to show real harm to a real person before a joke reaches a courtroom. Whatever the recorder decides, that change would need an act of Parliament.

You Might Also Be Interested In