The South Shore Press
← Back to Sports
Sports

Cooperstown Still Has to Judge Clemens and Bonds

On Nov. 21, President Trump said Roger Clemens belongs in the Hall of Fame immediately and that he would take a look at Barry Bonds. Both men have official records among the best in the sport, and Hall voters have kept them out under the character clause.

By Howard Roark
Cooperstown Still Has to Judge Clemens and Bonds
The main entrance of the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum stands in Cooperstown, New York, in a file photograph from November 23, 2022.Credit: Catsup31 / Wikimedia Commons (CC0 1.0)

President Donald Trump, two days after announcing a posthumous pardon for Pete Rose, used a Nov. 21 television interview to argue for two other stars who still have no plaque in Cooperstown. "Roger Clemens should be in the Hall of Fame immediately, and I'm going to take a look at Barry Bonds if you'd like me to do that," he said. Clemency is a presidential power, and election to the Hall of Fame is a private vote. The new request asks a museum to treat White House enthusiasm as a reason to move.

Clemens won 354 games and lost 184 over 24 seasons, with a 3.12 earned-run average and 4,672 strikeouts. Official records credit him with seven Cy Young Awards and the 1986 American League MVP award. Bonds, in 22 seasons, hit 762 home runs, the career record, and won the National League MVP award seven times. He finished with a .298 average, 2,935 hits and 1,996 runs batted in. Those totals are in the league's tables, and they have left Hall voters short of a plaque.

Hall of Fame rules tell the electors what to weigh, including a player's statistical record and ability, his integrity and sportsmanship, his character, and what he contributed to the clubs he played for. Election requires 75 percent of the ballots. In the 2022 writers' election, the final year Bonds and Clemens appeared on that ballot, Bonds received 66.0 percent and Clemens 65.2 percent. At the Winter Meetings in Orlando, a Contemporary Baseball Era Committee of 16 members elected Jeff Kent for the Class of 2026. Bonds and Clemens each received fewer than five votes. Under the Hall's rules, a candidate below that mark is ineligible for the next Contemporary Baseball Era player ballot, which is scheduled for 2028.

The public file that has followed both men is heavy with allegations and light on final criminal judgments. In June 2012, a federal jury found Clemens not guilty on every count of a six-count case that alleged he had lied to Congress and impeded its inquiry, after he denied, at a 2008 hearing, using performance-enhancing drugs. "Roger Clemens has never been proven to have taken drugs, and he swears that he didn't," Trump said. He also said Clemens "actually won a court case." The first of those sentences tracks the verdict. An acquittal means the government did not prove its case, and the Hall's voters still apply their own rule.

Bonds's criminal case ended in a reversal on April 22, 2015, when the Ninth Circuit, reviewing the case en banc, reversed a jury's obstruction-of-justice conviction that had rested on a rambling answer before a grand jury. The judges held that the record did not show the statement was material, and they barred a retrial on that count. Bonds has denied that he knowingly used steroids. The Dec. 13, 2007, report to the baseball commissioner by George J. Mitchell named both Bonds and Clemens among players alleged to have used performance-enhancing substances. Neither man carries a standing federal conviction from those allegations.

Trump himself treated the two files as distinct: Bonds, he said, "was a great player before the so-called drug excursion, if that ever took place." He also said Bonds's case was "a little bit different because there was very strong testimony and everything else." The public record on Bonds is more crowded than the record on Clemens. A crowded file remains a file of allegations, and the Hall is free to weigh it that way. The writers and the era committee have already used the character clause to keep both men out. If either name returns to a ballot, those electors will be entitled to apply that clause again. They will also have to own the standard they are using.

As a private museum, the Hall of Fame leaves its electors free to decide that the allegations against Bonds, or the suspicion that still attaches to Clemens in the public mind, outweigh 762 home runs or seven Cy Young Awards. That is the job the character clause assigns them. A president may praise a pitcher he admires and promise to study a slugger's case. The electors who already heard these arguments in the 2022 writers' election and at the Winter Meetings in Orlando still hold the only votes that count, and the character standard they use has to be one they can defend.

You Might Also Be Interested In