The South Shore Press
← Back to Business
Business

A 10 Percent Cap on Card Rates Would End Credit for Millions of Borrowers

Trump says he would back a 10 percent ceiling. The lender arithmetic shows credit ending below a score of about 745, with the rewards paid to prime cardholders still in place.

By Howard Roark
A 10 Percent Cap on Card Rates Would End Credit for Millions of Borrowers
A person holds a credit card above an open laptop, in a file photograph from August 21, 2021.Credit: Nenad Stojković / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

President Donald Trump said in a phone interview broadcast on Nov. 21 that he would team up with the Democrats who take over Congress in January on a 10 percent ceiling for card interest. Howard Roark's view is that a cap, if enacted, would end card credit for a large share of borrowers, because the average rate near 22 percent is what it costs to lend to the whole population and still survive a downturn.

S. 381, introduced Feb. 4, 2025 by Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont, an independent, and H.R. 1944, introduced March 6, 2025 by Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., would each bar any card rate above 10 percent until Jan. 1, 2031, and both remain in committee.

Rep. Andrew Garbarino, a Long Island Republican, holds a seat on the Financial Services Committee in the House. At the panel's Jan. 22 markup of H.R. 7056, Rep. Maxine Waters, D-Calif., offered an amendment holding card rates to 10 percent, and the chair ruled it not germane, so members never voted on it. Neither Garbarino nor Rep. Nick LaLota, who does not sit on the committee, has cosponsored either bill. A search of committee records, cosponsor lists and public statements found no vote or comment from either man on the cap.

The Federal Reserve's G.19 release puts the average commercial bank rate on card accounts assessed interest a little over 22 percent. Funding and operating costs take a slice of every revolving balance, and losses climb as scores fall, in a New York Fed study. Interchange income after rewards adds only a little.

A borrower with a strong score still pays well above the lender's costs, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau found, and a borrower with a weak score pays more still. The larger margin pays for the bad years, since the New York Fed researchers find that most of the extra return is pay for default risk, and that lending earns only a little more than ordinary bank loans after that premium is counted.

Once the rate is capped at 10 percent, the bills still let issuers collect fees up to the amount of interest. A high-score borrower would barely clear costs, leaving nothing for a recession, and a low-score borrower would lose money every year. Revenue covers costs only above a score near 745.

One objection holds that a ceiling already exists, and for banks none binds today. A national bank may charge the rate allowed in the state where it is headquartered, a rule the Supreme Court upheld in 1978. Delaware, South Dakota and Utah leave card rates to the contract, and the Congressional Research Service finds no general national cap. Ceilings do bind federal credit unions, at 18 percent through Sept. 10, 2027, and loans to active-duty servicemembers, at 36 percent. Break-even rates, once costs are reduced by fee and interchange income, run near 15 percent for a weaker credit, and adding the New York Fed's pay for recession risk lifts that figure to roughly 25 percent, above the credit union limit and below the military one.

Against similar cards without rewards, superprime rewards cardholders come out ahead each month while subprime ones pay more in interest than they collect. Rewards carry a subsidy that runs from the bottom of the score range to the top, and a Federal Reserve working paper using 2019 data estimates that they move roughly $15 billion a year from low-score cardholders to prime and superprime ones. The CFPB finds that subprime cardholders forfeit rewards at more than twice the overall rate.

A peer-reviewed study of the 2009 CARD Act, which bars lenders from raising rates on existing balances, finds that rates inside the subprime band bunched together, a second transfer. Rates dropped for the riskiest borrowers and rose for safer ones, and prices newly exceeded what a large share of the safest subprime borrowers would pay. Those who stay pay more than their own risk warrants, which in effect underwrites the riskier ones, though average prices fell.

Capping rates at 10 percent would repair neither transfer, since it ends lending below a score near 745 and removes much of the group that funds the rewards, while the bills never mention interchange or rewards and leave those perks with prime and superprime cardholders. The CFPB's year-end 2023 tally counts about 80 million cardholders below a score of 720.

Supporters of the cap dispute that it would end lending, and a Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator analysis finds that a 10 percent cap would cut lending only below a score of 600. John Thune, the Senate majority leader, and Speaker Mike Johnson both voiced doubt in January, so passage remains uncertain.

A cap would cut off credit for tens of millions of cardholders below a 720 score and leave the rewards transfer to the top in place. It could bring a deep recession, possibly a collapse in consumer spending.

You Might Also Be Interested In