$4.8 Million Accounting Mess Rocks Seneca Babcock
Months after an explosive South Shore Press investigation first exposed troubling financial irregularities at the Seneca Babcock Community Association, a new review by the Erie County Comptroller's Office has uncovered a staggering $4.8 million in transactions missing from the nonprofit's accounting

Months after an explosive South Shore Press investigation first exposed troubling financial irregularities at the Seneca Babcock Community Association, a new review by the Erie County Comptroller's Office has uncovered a staggering $4.8 million in transactions missing from the nonprofit's accounting records.
The findings represent a major development in a controversy first brought to light by South Shore Press columnist and former Congressman George Santos, whose reporting uncovered years of missing financial filings and serious questions about how the taxpayer-funded organization managed its money.
Within 24 hours of the initial Santos story becoming public, Seneca Babcock's longtime executive director, Brian Pilarski, resigned, and the organization announced plans to shut down most of its programs. The South Shore Press continued investigating, reporting on questionable financial disclosures and an independent auditor's rare "disclaimer of opinion," indicating insufficient financial records existed to verify the organization's finances. The newspaper's reporting eventually caught the attention of Long Island Assemblyman Joseph DeStefano, who demanded a state investigation.
After receiving no response from Gov. Kathy Hochul and Attorney General Letitia James, DeStefano escalated the matter by filing a formal federal whistleblower complaint through President Donald Trump's fraud reporting portal.
"Our taxpayers deserve answers," DeStefano told the South Shore Press. "When the state refuses to act, we have an obligation to take the information to whatever agency will."
Now, the Erie County Comptroller's Office has documented a financial recordkeeping disaster. County auditors identified 3,871 transactions totaling $4,808,983.09 omitted from Seneca Babcock's accounting records between 2021 and 2025. The financial mess didn't stop there. Auditors discovered that the Internal Revenue Service revoked Seneca Babcock's federal tax-exempt status in May 2020.
Nevertheless, the organization continued receiving Erie County funding through grants and contracts. Of 39 county funding arrangements examined, at least 25 required charitable nonprofit status. Nine grant applications submitted after the revocation affirmatively represented that Seneca Babcock maintained its federal tax exemption. The review also uncovered questionable IRS paperwork.
Financial information submitted as purported tax returns for 2019, 2020 and 2021 duplicated figures from a 2017 return. Two conflicting versions of the organization's 2021 return contained dramatically different financial information. Neither version could be located in the IRS filing records reviewed by auditors.
Another troubling discovery involved a reported $1 million building fund donation in 2017.
Auditors could not obtain sufficient documentation to reconcile the contribution with accounting records or determine how the money was ultimately spent. Questions also surrounded purchases through Amazon, eBay and PayPal. Auditors couldn't establish what was purchased, who authorized expenditures or whether merchandise was used for legitimate organizational purposes.
The review also identified $327,600 in sampled county payments to Seneca Babcock or Schiller Park Community Services that auditors could not fully reconcile with accounting records. Schiller Park, another community organization associated with Seneca Babcock, had its own federal tax-exempt status revoked in 2018. County records showed it received more than $1.5 million in payments between 2015 and 2021.
Auditors also raised serious concerns about the nonprofit's board oversight, financial reporting, construction spending and the handling of donated funds. The Comptroller's Office recommended independent financial reconciliation, stronger board oversight and tighter county controls over taxpayer-funded grants.Importantly, auditors did not conclude that $4.8 million was stolen or lost, nor did they establish that any individual committed wrongdoing.
The figure represents transactions omitted from accounting records, not a confirmed financial loss. But the findings raise serious questions about how millions of dollars flowed through an organization serving some of Buffalo's most vulnerable families, children and senior citizens. For months, the South Shore Press has been asking tough questions about Seneca Babcock's finances, government oversight and the protection of taxpayer dollars.
Now county auditors have documented widespread financial deficiencies, adding urgency to demands for a full forensic accounting and independent investigation.
You Might Also Be Interested In

Brookhaven Planning Board Schedules Nine Hearings for Thursday

Town and County Officials Move Up Police Substation Across From Mastic Beach Library Branch

Brookhaven Town Board Agenda Lists $500,000 for Holtsville Pool Work


