Elderly Shelter Island Man Gets $80,000 Back After Hackers Wired It Out of His Brokerage Account

An elderly Shelter Island man has recovered all $80,000 that was wired out of his brokerage account without his permission in September, after town police detectives and county prosecutors moved to have a credit union outside New York freeze the money, Raymond A. Tierney, the Suffolk County district attorney, announced on Nov. 18.
On or around Sept. 22, the man noticed the unauthorized transfer from his brokerage account and learned that the money had been sent to a regional federal credit union outside New York, the district attorney's office said. He sought help from Shelter Island police, and detectives there contacted the credit union at once to ask that every dollar be preserved. They then asked the Financial Crimes Bureau in the district attorney's office to help serve subpoenas for the records of the account that received the wire.
At the credit union, the fraud department froze the account while the credit union ran its own investigation, prosecutors said. Members of the Financial Crimes Bureau later spoke with the compliance officer at the credit union and with the out-of-state detective assigned to the case, and prosecutors confirmed the account was fraudulent, that it has been closed and that every dollar deposited in it went back to the man as the rightful owner. The district attorney's office is withholding the credit union's name and location because authorities outside Suffolk County are still investigating. The district attorney's release did not name a suspect or announce an arrest.
Tierney said "time is never our friend when it comes to hackers stealing funds from legitimate account holders," and urged residents to check their bank accounts routinely and to notify authorities immediately if they suspect a scam or a hack.
"Early notification provides investigators with the best opportunity to track fraudulent transactions, identify those responsible, and work with financial institutions and partner agencies to pursue recovery of stolen funds," said Shelter Island police Detective Sergeant Jack Thilberg. "Unfortunately, delays in reporting often reduce the chances of restitution, as funds can be quickly moved through a complex network of accounts and jurisdictions."
Michael McCoy, a deputy bureau chief in the Financial Crimes Bureau, handled the case along with Detective Andrew Graffagnino and Thilberg, both of the town police department on Shelter Island.
The FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center counted 201,266 complaints from people age 60 and older in 2025, with losses totaling about $7.7 billion, in its most recent annual report. The bureau's Recovery Asset Team, which works with banks to stop fraudulent transfers, recorded 642 incidents involving victims 60 and older that year, with about $65.4 million in losses, and helped freeze about $32.9 million of those funds. The FBI advises anyone who spots a fraudulent transfer to call the bank at once and ask it to recall the funds, and to file a complaint at ic3.gov with full transaction details.
Tierney's office also urged residents to guard passwords and account numbers, to ignore pop-ups and unsolicited texts or emails asking for account details, and to verify the identity of anyone requesting banking information before sharing it.
Recovery of the full $80,000 followed a prompt report to local police, and both Tierney and Thilberg urged other victims of scams or hacks to contact police quickly.
You Might Also Be Interested In

Blue Envelope Program for Neurodivergent, Deaf and Hard-of-Hearing Drivers Expected Before Full Suffolk Legislature After Committee Approval

Suffolk Lawmakers to Honor 18 Veterans of the Year as Lennon Readies Supply Drive for Homeless Veterans

Mastic Man Admits Raping and Beating Domestic Partner, Faces 18 Years in Prison at January Sentencing


