The South Shore Press
← Back to Local
Local

Huntington Board Closes Two Budget Sessions Without a Quorum

Supervisor Smyth ended the 2 p.m. and 6 p.m. special meetings on Nov. 20 after absent members sent letters, and no votes were taken on the resolutions posted for those sessions

By Gail Wynand
Huntington Board Closes Two Budget Sessions Without a Quorum
The historic Old Town Hall stands on Main Street in Huntington, in a file photograph from November 13, 2013.Credit: DanTD / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 3.0)

Huntington's Town Board closed two special meetings on Nov. 20 without voting on the 2027 budget. At 2 p.m. and again at 6 p.m., inside Town Hall at 100 Main Street, Supervisor Edmund J. Smyth said too few members were present to conduct business. None of the resolutions posted for those sessions received a vote.

On Nov. 17, Councilwoman Theresa Mari introduced 39 amendments aimed at the preliminary 2027 budget. She said the plan before the board would pierce the state tax cap by 18.39 percent and cited a cap limit of 2.68 percent. The amendments carried on votes of three ayes and two abstentions, with Mari, Councilman Dr. Dave Bennardo and Councilwoman Jennifer Hebert in favor. Smyth and Councilwoman Brooke Lupinacci abstained, saying the packet arrived too late. A roll-call vote to adopt the amended plan as the 2027 budget then failed 2-3, with Bennardo and Mari voting yes and Hebert, Lupinacci and Smyth voting no. Hebert said, "I'm voting against the budget."

The Nov. 20 agendas listed resolutions 2026-586 through 2026-594, to rescind eight of those amendments and revise a ninth. At 2 p.m., Town Clerk Andrew P. Raia read a notice signed by Smyth and letters from Bennardo and Mari. Bennardo, writing from a trip upstate, said he could not change a prior commitment and that notice arrived only 24 hours earlier. Mari objected under Town Law section 62, the provision that sets a two-day written-notice rule for special meetings of a town board. She wrote that an email sent at about 5:10 p.m. on Nov. 19 was the only outreach she received, and that she would stay away so her presence would not be treated as a waiver. "I expressly preserve my objection," the letter said.

Smyth then shut the official session, saying, "It's clear we don't have a quorum, so I'm gonna close the meeting." Remaining afterward, he said, "The emergency is that the budget does not balance. The math is wrong in it." He cited a projected $900,000 rise in tipping-fee revenue at the Covanta plant and a revenue share of 60 percent for Huntington and 40 percent for Smithtown, so $360,000 would go to Smithtown and had not been counted. "There are market forces in play here. We can't, we can't just hallucinate the numbers," he said. Hebert, who was present, said, "I'm learning now that there are flaws in some of the amendments."

Town Law section 109 requires towns outside Westchester and Monroe counties to adopt a budget by Nov. 20. If the board does not, subdivision 3 provides that the preliminary budget, with any changes the board has already approved, would become the budget for the coming fiscal year. Section 107 governs the contents of a preliminary budget. Smyth said he could ask the state for more time, and confirmation of an extension was still outstanding.

On the official livestream of the 6 p.m. session, held on the same agenda, the clerk read a statement from Lupinacci. She wrote that she had first planned to attend but concluded it was "not legally prudent to participate" after reviewing section 62. "As an attorney and elected official, I cannot participate in proceedings that fail to comply with New York State law," the statement said. Smyth said everything read about notice was "legally correct, although it's selective reading of the notice laws," and that "there's a simple cure, and that is attendance at the meeting." He said 24-hour notice went out once he concluded "the math in this budget doesn't compute properly." He then said Bennardo was out of town and Lupinacci and Mari were "at home tonight," so "we do not have a quorum" and "this is not a meeting on the record."

As of 6:20 p.m. on Nov. 20, the town had posted no minutes or recorded votes from either special session. The Nov. 17 amendments remained the last board changes to the preliminary budget. Under section 109, they would become the 2027 budget if no different plan is adopted by the close of Nov. 20.

You Might Also Be Interested In