The South Shore Press
← Back to Local
Local

East Hampton Town Board Fires Building Chief Richard Normoyle Jr.

A unanimous Nov. 19 vote ended his post as chief building inspector, with the official record citing civil service rules as the only stated ground

By Gail Wynand
East Hampton Town Board Fires Building Chief Richard Normoyle Jr.
East Hampton Town Hall stands along Pantigo Road in the Town of East Hampton, in a file photograph from April 8, 2022.Credit: Don Ramey Logan / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

The East Hampton Town Board voted 5 to 0 on Nov. 19 to fire Richard Normoyle Jr. as chief building inspector, closing a tenure that started Sept. 29, 2025. The measure, Resolution 2026-1667, was added after the agenda deadline under the title "Terminate Probationary Employee" and took effect that same day. Its only stated ground is that the town acted "in accordance with the applicable Civil Service law and rules."

Resolution 2025-1199, adopted Sept. 4, 2025, first hired him as principal building inspector at $135,000 a year, with a 26-week probation. Supervisor Kathee Burke-Gonzalez moved the appointment. It carried 4 to 0, with Councilmember Cate Rogers absent and Councilmembers Tom Flight, David Lys and Ian Calder-Piedmonte voting yes.

When he started, the office already faced long waits for permits and certificates of occupancy, and those delays later led the board, on March 10, to adopt Resolution 2026-465, which paused enforcement of a 2023 town law that required a fresh occupancy certificate when a property changed hands. The stay runs retroactively from Jan. 1, 2024, through Dec. 31, 2026, and was adopted 5 to 0 to give the department time to work through pending filings. A town FAQ issued with that vote said roughly six in ten of those updated-certificate applications involved work done without a permit.

A bribery case in the department, which began before he took the job, reached guilty pleas this fall. The Suffolk County district attorney's office, led by Raymond A. Tierney, said Evelyn Calderon, 47, of Mastic, a former senior office assistant in the department, pleaded guilty on Sept. 30 to five class D felonies of third-degree bribe receiving and five class A misdemeanors of official misconduct. Ryan Benitez, 38, a former town building inspector who lives in East Hampton, entered the same plea on Oct. 1. Both are due back before Justice Timothy P. Mazzei on Dec. 2 for sentencing. Accounts of the plea hearings said Mazzei told both defendants the promised terms were 840 hours of community service and five years of probation, to be formally imposed at that Dec. 2 sentencing.

In their plea allocutions, the two admitted they accepted cash from contractors in 2024 to speed permits and occupancy papers. The district attorney's office said Calderon advanced paying contractors ahead of the ordinary chronological line and, after taking a payment, immediately handed half to Benitez, who then rushed the inspections. The office said a permit that usually took months was issued in a matter of days once a payment arrived. The two had been indicted on the same charges on April 2.

The board promoted Normoyle to chief building inspector on June 16 at $140,000 a year under Resolution 2026-1002, effective retroactively to June 15, after he appeared on a Suffolk County civil service list. Rogers moved the promotion. It carried 4 to 0, with Flight absent. The resolution set a new 26-week probation, so he was still in that period when the board removed him.

Town figures for 2025 show the department issued 1,342 building permits and completed 3,257 inspections. It also issued 722 certificates of occupancy. Official 2026 goals included faster permit processing and clearing the existing backlog. The town also added staff, opened a fully online application system, OpenGov 2.0, on March 4, and retained outside firms to help review plans.

On July 2, at Normoyle's request, the board promoted Allison McDougall, then an administrative assistant in the department, into the provisional post of associate administrator. That vote, Resolution 2026-1084, carried 4 to 0, with Rogers absent. The Nov. 19 agenda and minutes contain no resolution naming a successor.

During the public portion on Nov. 19, David Buda told the board the firing came as a shock and called on officials to say why they had let him go, and the minutes record no reply from the dais.

Burke-Gonzalez moved the termination and Rogers seconded it, with Flight, Lys and Calder-Piedmonte also voting yes. Resolution 2026-1667 took effect that day, citing Civil Service law and rules as its only stated ground. The minutes contain no further statement of cause and no comment from Normoyle or from a lawyer appearing for him.

You Might Also Be Interested In