The South Shore Press
← Back to Local
Local

Third Man Charged in Suffolk Sex Trafficking Case That Began in Shirley

Police arrested Jason Magee, 39, in Riverhead on Nov. 18, six days after a second arrest in Mastic and 13 days after search warrants were served in Shirley

By Gail Wynand
Third Man Charged in Suffolk Sex Trafficking Case That Began in Shirley
A Long Island Rail Road station sign for Mastic and Shirley in a file photograph from November 12, 2014.Credit: DanTD / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Suffolk County police have charged a third man in a sex trafficking investigation that detectives say centered on a 29-year-old woman forced into prostitution. It is the third arrest in 13 days, a span that began with search warrants served at two Shirley properties on Nov. 5.

Detectives in the department's Human Trafficking Investigations Unit took Jason Magee, 39, into custody at about 5 p.m. on Nov. 18 at a Riverhead address, 1414 West Main Street, police said. The Warrants Section and the unit that handles telephone records and surveillance assisted. Police described Magee as undomiciled. He faces three sex trafficking counts, a first-degree count of aggravated sexual abuse and a second-degree count of promoting prostitution. Police held Magee in Third Precinct custody pending an arraignment set for Nov. 19 in Central Islip's First District Court. No public account of that hearing was available by the evening of Nov. 19.

Police allege that Magee and the two men arrested before him used violence to force the woman to have sex with clients. Police statements have yet to describe the specific role Magee is accused of playing, or how the three men knew one another.

The case dates to May 2025. Detectives concluded that Shirley resident Anton Trent, 50, was compelling the woman to work as a prostitute and violently sexually abusing her whenever she refused, police said. On Nov. 5, trafficking detectives served warrants at Nos. 14 and 17 on Moriches Middle Island Road and took Trent into custody there. He faces the same five counts later filed against Magee. He remained at the Third Precinct overnight, with arraignment in Central Islip set for Nov. 6.

Andy Joseph, 35, of Patchogue, became the second man charged. With help from the Fifth Precinct Gang Unit, detectives arrested him on Nov. 12 at about 6 p.m. at 630 Mastic Road, Mastic, police said, and accused him of violently forcing the woman into sex with clients. The charges against him include sex trafficking and second-degree promoting prostitution, along with a third-degree assault count and a seventh-degree drug possession count. Joseph was arraigned on Nov. 13 in the same Central Islip court.

Published accounts have offered three dates for Joseph's arrest. The police department announced it in an update added to its original Trent release on the evening of Nov. 12, saying the arrest had happened that day and that Joseph would spend the night in Third Precinct custody and go to court the next morning. A later police summary, issued after Magee's arrest, listed Nov. 13, the day Joseph appeared before a judge. One other account put the arrest on Nov. 5, the date Trent was taken in. The department's own same-day update fixes the arrest on Nov. 12.

Joseph is the only one of the three facing a drug count. Seventh-degree possession, a class A misdemeanor, applies to anyone who knowingly and unlawfully holds a controlled substance. Police have said nothing about what substance was involved or where it was found. Court filings in the three cases were unavailable in public online records on Nov. 19.

State law lists several ways to commit sex trafficking. Unlawfully supplying certain drugs to a person in order to impair judgment is one; compelling prostitution through force or the threat of injury is another. Police have yet to say which provisions underlie the trafficking counts against any of the men. Sex trafficking and first-degree aggravated sexual abuse are class B felonies, second-degree promoting prostitution is a class C felony, and third-degree assault is a class A misdemeanor.

The FBI took part in the investigation, as did investigators from the district attorneys' offices in both Nassau and Suffolk counties, police said. Suffolk units that assisted include the Narcotics Section, the Seventh Squad, the Criminal Intelligence Section, the Warrants Section and Seventh Precinct patrol and crime teams. Every charge filed so far is a state charge. A search of a public federal docket database on Nov. 19 found no federal case against Trent or Magee, and no federal release on the investigation had been posted.

Police noted that the charges are accusations and that each man is presumed innocent unless proven guilty. Detectives asked people who know anything about this case or any other to phone the trafficking unit at 631-854-7512. Tips can also go to Crime Stoppers, 1-800-220-TIPS.

Eighteen months of investigation produced three arrests in less than two weeks, each tied by police to the same woman and each sent to the same Central Islip courthouse. The charging papers filed there have yet to appear in public online records, which leaves Magee's precise role unresolved for now.

You Might Also Be Interested In