The South Shore Press
← Back to Sports
Sports

A.J. Ewing and Troy Melton Cash In on Long-Term Deals With the Mets and Tigers

Ewing brings rookie-record speed to a long-term deal in Queens, as Melton's 2.76 ERA in Detroit still has to answer a 20 percent strikeout rate

By FBaseball.com
A.J. Ewing and Troy Melton Cash In on Long-Term Deals With the Mets and Tigers
New York Mets center fielder A.J. Ewing bats as Detroit Tigers catcher Dillon Dingler looks on at Citi Field in Queens, in a file photograph from May 13, 2026.Credit: D. Benjamin Miller / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

The Mets and center fielder A.J. Ewing agreed Nov. 21 on an eight-year extension worth $95 million that includes a $25 million club option for 2035. One day earlier, the Tigers and right-hander Troy Melton agreed to six years and $46.5 million, plus a club option covering 2033. Both agreements would buy out every arbitration year of a homegrown fourth-round pick, and both players would carry everyday job security into 2027.

Fantasy managers should treat these two very differently on draft day.

Ewing, 22, debuted on May 12, quickly claimed the center field job and posted a .252/.324/.376 line with 11 home runs, 43 RBI, 55 runs and 25 stolen bases in 120 games, and those 25 steals broke the Mets rookie record of 24 that Mookie Wilson set in 1981. He placed ninth on the National League's rookie-award ballot, and he now anchors an outfield with Carson Benge and Juan Soto. Reason to be excited in Queens.

Ewing has always gotten his walks in the minors, and his 9% walk rate as a rookie in the big leagues had him getting reps at the top of the order as the season wore on.

Ewing swiped 70 bags in 81 attempts across three minor league levels in 2025 while posting a .315/.401/.429 line over 564 plate appearances. He kept running in the majors even when the bat went cold, stealing eight bases in August while hitting .171 with a .463 OPS and zero home runs that month.

Over his final 25 games, Ewing erased much of that August damage, hitting .318/.390/.489 with four homers, four steals and an .879 OPS, a finish that will have him appearing on a lot of sleeper lists next spring. Lefties still gave him trouble, holding him to a .666 OPS across 139 plate appearances, while he posted a .713 OPS against righties. A 25.4 percent strikeout rate is serviceable for a rookie.

Ewing belongs on draft boards as a steals specialist with upside in runs. The 11 bombs might be flukey but his youth portends to room for growth in the power department. A $95 million commitment likely guarantees playing time. Getting himself on base gives him a clear path past 30 steals. A likely spot near the top of the order in front of Soto and Lindor will get him piling up runs. A great cheap dynasty pick and a solid dude to target mid/late in redrafts.

Melton, a 2022 fourth-round pick out of San Diego State who turns 26 on December 3, missed the first two months of 2026 with elbow inflammation, returned to the mound for Detroit on May 24, then won seven of his first 14 starts against one loss while carrying a 1.49 ERA. He finished 8-5 with a 2.76 ERA and 94 strikeouts in 114.1 innings across 20 starts, matching the 2.76 ERA he posted over 45.2 innings as a swingman in 2025. The WHIP also helped you at 1.13.

Melton's strikeout rate sat at 20.0 percent, and his 7.9 percent walk rate leaves a K%-BB% that is undesirable. September exposed the risk, as he gave up 15 earned runs over 17 1/3 innings in four starts before forearm tightness landed him on the injured list for the final week. Tests showed no structural damage, and he fits near the front of a young rotation that includes Jackson Jobe and River Ryan after the Aug. 2 trade of Tarik Skubal.

Melton profiles as a mid-rotation ratio stabilizer, with downside to the ratios. Not sexy. A decent target after pick 250 next spring, but his ratios from 2026 likely get him bid up, and that is a fade. A 96 MPH fastball and decent command of the secondary stuff says he should miss more bats, but let someone else figure that out. The Tigers commitment means he will be in that rotation, so worth watching.

Two extensions in two days. Ewing is a clear buy for us. Melton is a more valuable real world option than fantasy asset, for now.

You Might Also Be Interested In