The South Shore Press
← Back to Sports
Sports

The League That Banned Pete Rose Now Sells Bets on Its Own Games

President Trump announced a posthumous pardon for Pete Rose on Nov. 19, while the league that banned him for betting now profits from official sportsbook partnerships. Hall vote on deck.

By Howard Roark
The League That Banned Pete Rose Now Sells Bets on Its Own Games
Cincinnati Reds player-manager Pete Rose, left, talks with Los Angeles Dodgers manager Tommy Lasorda on the field at Dodger Stadium in Los Angeles, in a file photograph from April 7, 1985.Credit: Jayne Kamin / Los Angeles Times, UCLA Library (CC BY 4.0)

President Donald Trump announced on Nov. 19 that he had given a "Complete and Total Pardon" to Pete Rose, baseball's career hits leader, who died on Sept. 30, 2024, when he was 83. The post did not name an offense. Rose was convicted in a 1990 federal tax case and served a prison term. A pardon issued after death writes a formal ending on a record that had already been closed for a generation. The Hall of Fame question the announcement raised remains open.

In August 1989, Rose, who had collected a major league record 4,256 hits, went onto the permanently ineligible list by agreement after Commissioner A. Bartlett Giamatti reviewed an investigation by the lawyer John M. Dowd. The report documented that Rose, then managing the Cincinnati Reds, had bet on major league games in 1987, a violation of the sport's Rule 21. The Hall of Fame later adopted a rule, in 1991, barring anyone on that ineligible list from consideration for a plaque.

About eight months after the ban, on April 20, 1990, Rose pleaded guilty in Cincinnati federal court on two felony counts of submitting false federal income-tax forms. He admitted leaving $354,968 off the income listed on those forms across four tax years. On July 19, Judge S. Arthur Spiegel sentenced him to five months in prison, a $50,000 fine, three months confined to a halfway house or to a community treatment facility, and 1,000 hours of unpaid community work. "I will serve my sentence, pay my debt to society and get on with my life," Rose said in a statement that day.

The tax case had already ended in a completed prison term when, on May 13, 2025, Commissioner Rob Manfred removed Rose and 16 other deceased people from the permanently ineligible list, after a petition from Rose's family. "Once an individual has passed away, the purposes of Rule 21 have been served," Manfred wrote. "Obviously, a person no longer with us cannot represent a threat to the integrity of the game." Jane Forbes Clark, the Hall of Fame's board chair, said that anyone taken off the list becomes eligible for consideration. The Classic Baseball Era Committee is due to meet in December 2027. A place on that ballot, and a pardon from the White House, would still leave the decision to that committee, which has not voted on him.

Trump's post said Rose "was treated terribly by Major League Baseball in not allowing him to go into the Baseball Hall of Fame. Politics, I guess!" The Hall of Fame is a private museum, and a pardon does not bind it.

In 2023 the league announced a multi-year agreement that made FanDuel one of two official sportsbook partners with shared category rights, years after it had treated betting as an offense that justified exile for life. DraftKings had received a matching designation in 2021. As recently as Nov. 10, 2025, the commissioner's office, working with those sportsbook partners, announced new limits on pitch-level wagers, and a FanDuel executive was identified in the release as an official sportsbook partner of the league.

Rose crossed a real line when he bet on major league games as the Reds' manager, a practice still prohibited for anyone working in the sport. The Dowd investigation and the ban that followed had a factual basis. Manfred has already said a dead man cannot endanger the sport's honesty. The Hall's committee can weigh the betting record in 2027 in a sport that now books official revenue from the same vice.

The pardon is an act of clemency for a man who served his time and has been in the ground for more than two years. When the Hall's committee meets in December 2027, it can judge the player who piled up 4,256 hits without taking instruction from a league that now sells the action it once used to banish him.

You Might Also Be Interested In