Video Vault: Catholic Nuns Bravely Battle and Sue New York State Over Assisted Suicide Law Mandate

A federal lawsuit challenging New York's Medical Aid in Dying Act is moving forward, with the Carmelite Sisters for the Aged and Infirm seeking emergency relief before the law takes effect Aug. 5. South Shore Press Managing Editor Stefan Mychajliw spoke with Becket Fund President and CEO Mark Rienzi, lead counsel for the nuns, about the case.

Stefan Mychajliw: Mark, give us the big picture. What is this lawsuit about?

Mark Rienzi: New York is trying to force religious ministries that oppose assisted suicide to participate in it. The state wants Catholic ministries to counsel patients about assisted suicide and refer them elsewhere if they refuse. The Carmelite Sisters and other Catholic orders believe that violates their faith and constitutional rights.

Mychajliw: Where does the case stand?

Rienzi: We've filed suit and will ask a federal judge for an emergency order before Aug. 5, when the law takes effect. The sisters will not comply with a mandate that conflicts with their religious beliefs, so we're asking the court to protect their constitutional rights.

Mychajliw: Tell us about the Carmelite Sisters.

Rienzi: They've cared for the elderly and infirm for nearly 100 years. Their mission is to treat every patient with dignity, compassion and love through the natural end of life. They believe every life has equal worth and are committed to caring for patients, not hastening death. Mychajliw: How are the sisters handling this legal fight?

Rienzi: Their faith is extraordinary. They're not motivated by politics. They've dedicated their lives to serving others and want to continue caring for anyone in need, regardless of background or beliefs.

Mychajliw: What happens next?

Rienzi: We'll ask the court to act before Aug. 5. We believe the Constitution protects religious organizations from being forced to violate their beliefs. Until then, the sisters remain focused on the mission they've carried out for generations—providing compassionate care to New York's most vulnerable while defending what they believe are fundamental religious freedoms.