The South Shore Press
← Back to Local
Local

Port Jefferson Teen Gets Six to 18 Years for Fatal Livestreamed Crash in Centereach

Matthew Papile was 16 when he drove a stolen Land Rover while high on marijuana and broadcast the drive on Instagram, prosecutors said

By Gail Wynand
Port Jefferson Teen Gets Six to 18 Years for Fatal Livestreamed Crash in Centereach
Middle Country Road at North Hammond Road and South Howell Avenue in Centereach in a file photograph from September 21, 2017.Credit: DanTD / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Matthew Papile, the Port Jefferson teenager who streamed his own drive on Instagram as a stolen Land Rover he was steering slammed into a 73-year-old woman's car in Centereach in 2024, received a prison term of six to 18 years on Nov. 19, District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney of Suffolk County announced. The court also ordered his driver's license revoked.

Papile, now 18, was 16 on the night of May 4, 2024, when the SUV he was steering eastbound on Middle Country Road rammed a 1994 Toyota Corolla from behind. The Corolla's driver, Marion Napolitano, died at Stony Brook University Hospital. Her son, who was riding in the front passenger seat, suffered a traumatic brain injury.

"This defendant's decision to drive while impaired in a stolen car, while livestreaming his recklessness, is indefensible," Tierney said. "A woman lost her life and another victim suffered a traumatic brain injury as a direct result of Matthew Papile's actions. Today's sentencing holds him accountable for the devastation he caused."

Papile lives in Port Jefferson. The collision took place on the Centereach stretch of Middle Country Road, prosecutors said.

The SUV, a blue 2008 Land Rover LR2, had vanished from a Coram driveway, and its owner called police about it that morning. Around 9:10 that night, prosecutors said, Papile clipped the side of another car in the eastbound lanes and kept going. He then swerved from lane to lane, cut in front of other drivers and sped until he rear-ended Napolitano, whose car left the roadway and struck a telephone pole and then a tree.

The stolen SUV spun and stopped in the middle lane. Papile climbed out and fled on foot. Three bystanders, one of them a Suffolk County police officer who was off duty, chased him and held onto him until patrol officers arrived.

Officers at the scene saw signs that he was high on marijuana and arrested him, prosecutors said. He admitted he had smoked, agreed to a blood test, and toxicology found tetrahydrocannabinol, or THC, in his blood. Investigators afterward retrieved his Instagram videos, and prosecutors said they captured his erratic driving in the stolen vehicle up to the moment of the crash.

In the days after the crash, Suffolk police withheld the driver's name because of his age. The charges police filed that weekend covered drug-impaired driving, leaving the scene of a crash that caused a death and a third-degree count of holding stolen property. Police described the injured passenger at the time as a man of 50.

Prosecutors later took the case to adult court, where the district attorney's office said Papile was tried as an adult. On Sept. 15, 2026, he pleaded guilty in front of Karen Kerr, an acting state Supreme Court justice. The most serious count was aggravated vehicular homicide, which state law classifies as a class B felony. Second-degree manslaughter and aggravated vehicular assault, both class C felonies, were also part of the plea, along with second-degree assault, fleeing a fatal incident without reporting it and possessing stolen property, a third-degree count. He also admitted a drug-impaired driving misdemeanor, plus reckless driving, which is a traffic infraction.

"Today's guilty plea underscores the outrageous and utterly unacceptable decision to get behind the wheel of a stolen vehicle while impaired and drive recklessly through the streets of Suffolk County," Tierney said on the day of the plea. "The defendant's choices on that day were selfish, lethal and they ruined lives. We continue to express our condolences to the victim's family."

Sean Dixon, the defense lawyer who represented Papile, said in September that his client was "extremely remorseful."

The district attorney's office announced at the plea that sentencing was set for Oct. 15, 2026. It took place on Nov. 19 instead, and the term imposed matches the range Papile was told to expect when he admitted the charges.

Raymond Varuolo and Jeffrey Rosenheck, both assistant district attorneys in the office's Vehicular Crime Bureau, handled the case, and Valentin Rosado, a Suffolk police detective, assisted the investigation, the district attorney's office said.

The sentencing brings the trial court case to a close two and a half years after a crash broadcast live on Instagram. Papile, whose name police withheld in 2024 because he was 16, now faces as long as 18 years in prison, and Napolitano's son, prosecutors said, remains seriously injured from the crash that killed his mother.

You Might Also Be Interested In