The South Shore Press
← Back to Opinion
Opinion

New Jersey Taxpayers Get the Bill for Sherrill's Deportation Defense Fund

Gov. Mikie Sherrill nearly tripled state money for lawyers in immigration removal cases, a $20.2 million commitment made while Trenton still runs a structural deficit

By Howard Roark
New Jersey Taxpayers Get the Bill for Sherrill's Deportation Defense Fund
New Jersey Governor Mikie Sherrill speaks at the New Jersey Film Expo, in a file photograph from April 30, 2026.Credit: Demetri Andriani / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

On Nov. 13, Gov. Mikie Sherrill and Stephen Cha, her human services commissioner, announced that New Jersey had committed all $20.2 million in a state immigration legal aid program, split across 10 providers that will represent residents in detention or removal cases. The program, formally the Detention and Deportation Defense Initiative, had $8.2 million to spend in past fiscal years and now has nearly three times that amount for fiscal 2027. Trenton has also promised to cover every detainee at Delaney Hall, the federal immigration detention center in Newark, who meets the income test and lacks counsel.

In the state's telling, the program exists because people in deportation cases generally have no right to a lawyer paid for by the government, unlike defendants in criminal court. Sherrill said in the announcement that "everyone in this country is entitled to due process and a fair hearing under the law." Cha said access to counsel "promotes fairer, more efficient immigration proceedings" and described the allocation as the biggest the program has ever received. When the increase was unveiled in June, Senate Majority Leader Teresa Ruiz, who said she wrote the budget resolution behind the increase, argued that nobody's future should turn on a hearing "lasting mere minutes, without legal representation." Faster, cleaner hearings are a goal conservatives can share.

About $13 million stays with the program's existing network, led by Legal Services of New Jersey, which shares its grant with the American Friends Service Committee and the law schools at Seton Hall and Rutgers. About $5 million goes to three newcomers with removal defense experience: Church World Service, the New Jersey Consortium for Immigrant Children and the state's own Office of the Public Defender. Catholic Charities of the Archdiocese of Newark and the Immigration and American Citizenship Organization will split about $1.2 million to build capacity, and the International Rescue Committee will collect about $1 million to serve as the coordinating entity. The department itself says that the chosen groups must still recruit lawyers and staff before the expanded program runs at full strength.

On June 30, Sherrill signed a $60.7 billion budget that, by her administration's own figures, carries a $1.35 billion structural deficit. That figure improves on the shortfall of more than $3 billion projected when she took office, and it still leaves the state spending beyond its recurring revenue. Trenton chose this moment to add $12 million to a single program. Anthony M. Bucco, the Senate Republican leader, made the point in June, noting that school districts were weighing whether to trim sports, student services and basic skills programs even as Trenton found money for this expansion. Sherrill called the spending plan an affordability budget. Families in districts trimming those programs are entitled to ask how deportation defense ranked ahead of their children.

Immigration enforcement belongs to Washington, and removal cases are heard in the federal immigration system. New Jersey has no say over who is detained or how long a case runs. By pledging counsel to every low-income detainee at Delaney Hall who lacks a lawyer, Trenton has tied its own spending to a federal detention population it cannot control. Delaney Hall is a 1,000-bed facility owned by GEO Group, and it began housing ICE detainees on May 1, 2025. GEO has said its 15-year contract with ICE, which the company values at about $1 billion, includes detainees' access to legal counsel. If federal detention in Newark grows, the pressure on this state line item grows with it.

The state's announcement describes eligibility in terms of low income and New Jersey residency, plus the Delaney Hall pledge for detainees without counsel. Nothing in the release mentions screening by criminal history or by the strength of a case. Online critics have described the program as a defense fund for "criminal illegal aliens," a characterization that goes further than anything the state has said, and the state has published no breakdown of its clients. Taxpayers are left with no public way to know how the money will be used case by case, and an income test alone offers no assurance that dollars go to the strongest claims.

The administration also points to a companion effort, the Rapid Legal Response Initiative, which the state says has already drawn more than 150 attorneys into training on habeas corpus petitions and federal litigation. Volunteer lawyers offering their time are a sound model, and a growing volunteer network makes a nearly threefold jump in paid grants harder to justify.

Due process in immigration court is a legitimate concern, and Congress holds the authority to address it in the federal system that hears these cases. New Jersey's leaders made state taxpayers the backstop for that federal process, at nearly triple the old cost, in a year when their own budget still does not balance on a recurring basis. If the program continues, legislators should require the Office of New Americans to report how many cases the $20.2 million funds, how many clients win relief and whether any screening applies, so residents can weigh the return on their money before the next budget is written.

You Might Also Be Interested In