Mamdani's Grocery Math Leaves the City's Private Stores Out of the Equation
Pressed on stage about grocery margins of 1% to 4%, Mayor Zohran Mamdani said his city stores will be taxpayer subsidized and meant for every New Yorker, and left unanswered how private grocers compete with that

Mayor Zohran Mamdani took the stage at Jazz at Lincoln Center in Manhattan on Wednesday, Nov. 18, for an interview at an annual business summit and faced the one question his grocery plan has never answered. The interviewer, Andrew Ross Sorkin, noted that supermarkets typically earn margins of 1% to 4% while the city intends to sell food at a 30% discount, and he asked how that subsidy would affect "the other supermarkets in the city" over the long term. He never addressed the private grocers, and the interview ended minutes later without a return to them.
The mayor's office says five municipal stores will open, one per borough, starting with a Hunts Point site called The Peninsula by the end of 2027, with East Harlem's La Marqueta also on the list. City Hall has budgeted $70 million in capital money for the five sites. The city will pay the rent and the property tax bills, and a private operator chosen by competitive bid will run daily operations. A core basket covering every fresh fruit and vegetable along with meat and seafood, plus about 20 more categories of staples and dairy, is to be priced 30% below typical New York retail. Officials project average household savings of about $90 a month, and the July announcement says the discount applies to every shopper regardless of income.
Grocery retail runs on pennies. FMI, the trade group for food retailers, reports that grocers kept an average net profit of 2.1% of sales in 2025, and its annual survey found about 11% of responding retailers lost money on operations. Kroger reported net earnings of $1.016 billion on $147.6 billion in sales for fiscal 2025, according to company results, which comes to less than a cent on each dollar. A 30% price cut equals roughly fourteen times the industry's average profit, far more than any gain in efficiency could cover.
Taxpayers cover the difference. The city's request for proposals calls them Affordability Payments, which fill operating deficits from selling the basket below retail. No dollar figure for them has been published. The city's economic development corporation told bidders in September that each operator will file a yearly budget and that final payments depend on agency approval and on "City funding availability." The $70 million pays for buildings, while the yearly subsidy runs for a contract term that a published account of the solicitation sets at ten years or more.
Mamdani did not dispute any of it. "It's going to be subsidized," he told the audience, according to video of the exchange and published transcripts. He then stated the principle behind it: "when society deems something necessary for the public, then we subsidize its creation and its operation." He likened food to the subway and public schools. Asked whether the stores were meant for the executives in the room or for a needier group, he said, "I want the public sector to be so good that the people in this room, no matter how much money they may have in their pocket, will choose to use that public sector." The stores, he added, should be "for any New Yorker."
No private train line competes on the next corner at full fare, while grocery retail is crowded with private sellers, and by the mayor's own count the city has "more than a thousand supermarkets." Owners of neighborhood stores have said publicly that their margins run near 1% after rent, insurance and wages. A family saving $90 a month at a city store moves that spending away from the independent grocer nearby. An owner earning 2% cannot match a 30% cut to keep that customer, and few investors will build a new store a few blocks from a rival whose losses are covered by City Hall.
That chain of events is the classic warning about socialism, now applied to the produce aisle. When government underwrites the price of a basic good and invites everyone to use it, private sellers lose customers they cannot win back on equal terms, and over time the public option becomes the main option. Its quality then answers to a budget line, and shoppers lose the leverage of walking out. Under the city's own design, an agency reviews and approves each operator's yearly budget, and any bonus fees are tied to performance metrics the city sets.
Five stores cannot serve a city this size, so officials decide which neighborhoods get the 30% discount and which go without. City Hall and its development agency have already made the first two choices. If the subsidy runs short in a lean budget year, officials will also decide which stores keep their prices low, a rationing call made in City Hall, far from any checkout line.
The mayor described the plan as five stores in a vast market. His stated goal reaches much further: a public option good enough that every New Yorker prefers it, funded indefinitely by taxpayers and priced below anything a private competitor can match. Asked directly what happens to the grocers already feeding the city, he answered with a lecture on public goods and left the private stores unaddressed. The City Council, which controls the budget, should demand that answer in writing before it funds the first store.
You Might Also Be Interested In

The MTA Responds to Last Week's Guest Column on Federal Transit Funding

New York City Lifted the Working Families Line Over the Conservatives

Ortt Returns as Senate GOP Leader With Long Island Ranks Thinned by Election Losses


