New York City Lifted the Working Families Line Over the Conservatives
Unofficial returns as of Nov. 18 put the Working Families line ahead of the Conservative line in a governor's race for the first time, and the Conservative line still leads outside the five boroughs and in Suffolk

New York prints its general election ballots in rows, and since the 2010 governor's race the first row below the two major parties has belonged to the Conservative Party. That run looks set to end. Unofficial figures for the Nov. 3 election, tallied as of the morning of Nov. 18, put Gov. Kathy Hochul's Working Families Party total well ahead of Bruce Blakeman's Conservative total, and state election law orders every party row by its showing for governor. The Working Families advantage is overwhelmingly a New York City result. The Conservative line still leads across most of the suburbs and upstate.
Conservatives organized in 1962 because they regarded the state's existing parties, including the Republicans, as too liberal. The Working Families Party arrived in 1998 and qualified that November when Peter Vallone drew 51,325 votes on its line for governor, barely over what was then a 50,000 vote bar. Each party depends on fusion, the New York practice that lets one candidate run on several party lines and adds the votes together. A voter can back the Democrat or the Republican while signaling which wing of that coalition deserves the credit.
Certified state results show the Conservative line beat the Working Families line in every governor's race from 1998 through 2022. George Pataki took 348,727 Conservative votes in 1998. The nearest call came in 2006, when John Faso's 168,654 Conservative votes edged Eliot Spitzer's 155,184 on the Working Families line. The Working Families line sank in 2018 to 114,478 votes for Andrew Cuomo, while Marc Molinaro collected 253,624 as the Conservative nominee. Four years ago Lee Zeldin drew 313,187 Conservative votes, while Hochul's Working Families line drew 261,323.
A public campaign financing commission created in the 2019 budget recommended that a party keep its line only by drawing 130,000 votes in every race for governor and president, or a 2 percent share when that figure runs higher. On March 12, 2020, Ralph Boniello, a justice of the state Supreme Court in Niagara County, voided the commission's work in a Working Families Party suit. The Legislature then wrote the same thresholds into the budget Cuomo signed on April 3, 2020. A later federal opinion records that commissioner Jay Jacobs pointed to remarks by Dan Cantor, who then ran the Working Families Party, that a higher bar would "require minor parties to show substantial popular support and will reduce ballot clutter."
The Green and Libertarian parties fell short in the 2020 presidential count and lost their lines. Federal courts let the law stand, from the Second Circuit's 2021 ruling in SAM Party v. Kosinski to the Supreme Court's refusal in October 2023 to hear the Libertarian and Green appeal. The first statewide Working Families lead over the Conservative line came in that presidential race, when Joe Biden's Working Families tally reached 386,010, against 295,657 on Donald Trump's Conservative line. On the unofficial 2026 count, this is the first governor's race in which the Working Families line has finished ahead.
The city's Board of Elections, in unofficial returns as of Nov. 4, counted 207,873 Working Families votes across the five boroughs and 27,740 Conservative votes, more than half of the Working Families statewide total. Brooklyn alone supplied about a quarter of that statewide total, with 93,479 votes, or 15 percent of the governor vote there, in unofficial state county figures. Outside the city the order flips. Subtracting the city count from the statewide unofficial total leaves about 207,000 Conservative votes against about 166,000 for the Working Families side.
Suffolk County remains the Conservative stronghold. The county board's unofficial count gives Blakeman 30,281 votes on the Conservative line, more than any other county and more than double the 14,209 Hochul drew there on the Working Families line. The Conservative Party's highest shares came in western and rural upstate counties, led by Niagara at nearly 9 percent. In unofficial county returns, the Working Families line topped the Conservative line in 14 of 62 counties, up from seven in the certified 2022 count, mostly in the five boroughs and in Hudson Valley or upstate counties with large cities or colleges. On the unofficial statewide count, the Conservative line is down roughly 78,000 votes from its certified 2022 total of 313,187, a drop of about a quarter, and about 11,000 of that decline is in Suffolk. Conservative state chairman Gerard Kassar has said Mayor Zohran Mamdani "was urging votes for Hochul on the Working Families line."
The returns remain unofficial until the canvass is complete. The 2030 governor's race will set the rows again.
You Might Also Be Interested In

Ortt Returns as Senate GOP Leader With Long Island Ranks Thinned by Election Losses

Adams Cites Paris Unrest as He Urges Mamdani to Reverse Disbanding of NYPD Protest Unit

Mamdani and Tisch Disband the NYPD Strategic Response Group


