Democrats Credit Even-Year Election Law for Local Gains as Suffolk Party Feuds Over Close Races
The 2023 law that moved town and county races onto the federal-year ballot survived a state court challenge and still faces a federal suit, while Suffolk Democrats argue over a comptroller race their candidate trails by 6,548 votes in unofficial returns.

New York Democrats are crediting a 2023 law that moved many town and county contests onto the even-year November ballot for a string of local wins this month. In Suffolk County, a narrow deficit in the comptroller race has reopened a fight among Democrats over why the party did not win more.
The measure, Chapter 741 of the state's 2023 session laws, was signed by Gov. Kathy Hochul on Dec. 22, 2023, and took effect Jan. 1, 2025. It shifts offices such as town supervisor and county legislator to even years and exempts county clerks, sheriffs and New York City offices. Under the state Board of Elections transition plan, officials elected in 2025 to two-year posts got one-year terms, and those elected that year to four-year posts next face voters in 2028.
The Court of Appeals, the state's highest court, unanimously upheld the law on Oct. 16, 2025, turning back a home rule challenge brought by several counties and towns. "We hold that there is no express or implied constitutional limitation on the legislature's authority to enact the Even Year Election Law and therefore affirm," Judge Michael Garcia wrote. On March 23, the U.S. Supreme Court denied a petition for review filed by Rockland County and other plaintiffs.
A separate suit, with the state Republican committee and the Suffolk and Nassau Republican committees among the plaintiffs, remains open in federal court in Central Islip. On June 29, U.S. District Judge Gary R. Brown dismissed with prejudice every claim brought by local governments, Suffolk County and Brookhaven Town among them, and all claims against the state, Hochul and the Board of Elections. The remaining plaintiffs refiled July 9 against the board's four commissioners, and the docket showed the case still pending as of a Nov. 12 filing.
State Democratic Chairman Jay Jacobs has credited the switch for his party's results, pointing to a Democratic win for Erie County clerk and three added Democratic seats in the Dutchess County Legislature. In the Town of Hempstead, Democrat Joseph Scianablo unseated Republican Supervisor John Ferretti, a named plaintiff in the federal case, 141,674 votes to 131,515, or 51.7 percent to 48 percent, in unofficial Nassau County returns.
Enrollment already favors Democrats statewide. A Nov. 2 review of state Board of Elections data by NYPIRG, the state's Public Interest Research Group, put Democrats at 47.89 percent of enrolled voters and Republicans at 22.14 percent, both down from 2010.
Suffolk split its ballot. Republicans held both congressional seats, while Democrats captured the 1st Senate District and the 3rd Assembly District, where Joshua Slaughter unseated Republican Assemblyman Joseph DeStefano by 908 votes in unofficial counts. In the race for county comptroller, Republican Daniel Losquadro, Brookhaven's highway superintendent, led Democrat Jon Estreich 265,160 to 258,612 in the county's unofficial tally, with results not yet certified.
That margin has sharpened a quarrel inside the county party. Estreich resisted a summer push by party leaders to drop him from the ballot. Anthony Portesy, the party's original candidate for county clerk, dropped out, leaving Republican Clerk Vincent Puleo with only write-in opposition. Critics of Chairman Rich Schaffer allege he pressed both men to accept judgeship nominations that would have cleared their ballot lines for Republicans. Estreich turned the offer down. Schaffer's camp has denied wrongdoing, and in a statement it called separate allegations that he bribed and threatened committee members "pathetic and ridiculous."
Schaffer, county chairman since 2000, defeated Southold Democratic Chairwoman Kathryn Casey Quigley on Sept. 22 after 12 rounds of voting, taking 113,010 weighted committee votes, or 57.2 percent, to her 84,234.
Suffolk Republican Chairman Jesse Garcia has described the county as a "big red brick wall" against the Democratic wave. A testament to the fine work of Garcia and his team.
The federal claims against the four election commissioners remained pending as of a Nov. 12 filing, and the comptroller race will be settled when the county certifies its results. The calendar change itself is still working through local offices. Under Chapter 741, a covered county or town office whose current term ends in 2027 will still be filled that November, but the winner will serve a term cut by one year so the seat moves to an even year. Officials elected in 2025 to four-year posts next face voters in 2028, alongside the presidential race. By 2030, when the last of the shortened terms run out, every office the law covers will be chosen only in even-numbered years.
You Might Also Be Interested In

Mamdani and Tisch Disband the NYPD Strategic Response Group

Police Kill Van Driver on Belt Parkway After 911 Callers Feared an Abduction

MTA Wants More Federal Cash As Long Islanders Pay The Price


