The South Shore Press
← Back to Opinion
Opinion

Vance Is Right That the Midterms Were No Rejection of the Trump Agenda

MAGA Base Is Angry About Failure to Deliver, and the Record Supports That View

By Howard Roark
Vance Is Right That the Midterms Were No Rejection of the Trump Agenda
Credit: Sgt. Nathan Winter / U.S. Army

In a television interview Nov. 16, Vice President JD Vance dismissed the idea that the midterms repudiated the president's agenda. "I think that the people who look at 2026 and they say that's a rejection of what Donald Trump ran on. No, no, no," he said. He added that "the Democrats in 2026, they were running on some of the very same themes that Donald Trump ran on in 2024." Vance's reading is right. Voters love the agenda. They simply feel betrayed because of the administration's failure to deliver, and the record supports that.

The losses were heavy. By unofficial counts as of Nov. 16, Democrats won 256 House seats and will hold at least 55 Senate seats, counting two independents in their caucus. Democrats take control when the new Congress is sworn in Jan. 3.

Among the agenda items not delivered upon, the promise on war comes first. On election night in 2024, Trump told supporters, "I'm not going to start a war. I'm going to stop wars." In January, U.S. forces captured Venezuelan leader Nicolás Maduro in Caracas. On Feb. 28, the United States and Israel opened a war on Iran. Diplomatic efforts to end it remain stalled, and U.S. forces still blockade Iranian ports, though Trump said last week that the war's military phase had essentially ended. In the national exit poll, 63 percent of voters called the military action against Iran the wrong decision. Supporters who took the 2024 pledge of restraint at face value can fairly call that abandonment.

Prices carried the same message. The Bureau of Labor Statistics said consumer prices rose 3.7 percent over the year ending in September, up from 3.4 percent in August, with gasoline up 34.2 percent over the year. In the national exit poll, close to eight in 10 voters said inflation had caused their families moderate or severe hardship. Vance says the 2024 campaign promised lower prices and more affordability. With gasoline 34 percent costlier than a year ago, families can fairly doubt that the promise was kept. Vance acknowledged the shortfall in the interview, saying, "There's a lot of progress that's been made, but not enough has been made."

Mortgages cost more as well. Freddie Mac's weekly Primary Mortgage Market Survey put the average 30-year fixed mortgage rate at 7.11 percent for the week of Nov. 12, compared with 6.24 percent a year earlier. The rate has fallen four weeks in a row, yet a buyer financing the same loan amount still pays more each month than a year ago. Vance said young people are telling Republicans they want to start families and afford homes.

Immigration is one area where Republicans kept an edge. Even in a wave election against the party, more voters picked Republicans as better on immigration, in the national exit poll and in a separate national poll. This has more to do with the Democrats' open pledge to open the border and not enforce immigration laws at all. A low bar to clear. Immigration was a central plank of the 2024 campaign, and despite record low border crossings, the MAGA base has been frustrated with some of the rollback of deportation efforts.

Election law shows the plainest gap between promise and result. The SAVE America Act would require proof of citizenship to register to vote and photo identification to cast a ballot. The House passed it 218 to 213 on Feb. 11. On March 26, a Senate vote to end debate on an amendment to the House-passed bill failed 53 to 47. Ending debate takes 60 votes, and the bill has not become law. Vance acknowledged the setback, saying, "Well, we certainly didn't get the Save America Act passed."

Across the core campaign pledges from 2024, the administration has failed to deliver, and in some cases has done the opposite of what was promised. Vance puts the lesson plainly. Voters, he says, "want us to deliver more of those things." He is right, and the election results reflect the frustration of the base.

That damage is now done, and the party must now confront Congress and many red states now controlled by the opposition party, which senses an opportunity to cement long-term control. The path to regaining control of the government must begin with building back trust. No small task.

Trust could begin to be restored with this lame duck session. Republicans have less than seven weeks before Democrats take control of Congress. Vance said voters want Republicans to deliver more, and this window is the party's last chance to act while it still holds both chambers. A credible exit from the Iran war, finally confirming the President's lengthy backlog of judicial appointments and real relief on household costs would be the clearest way to answer his own call for more wins. Early indications are not promising, however. Senate Majority Leader John Thune was re-elected to lead Senate Republicans on Nov. 10 and said that evening that they were "committed to being here and doing whatever it takes to finish this legislative session strong." Two days later he sent senators home for a long weekend, even though Sen. Ashley Moody had called for "no breaks, no weekends, no holidays" and Sen. Rick Scott had urged Republicans to work through the holidays. It is unclear why Senator Thune was chosen to lead the caucus again, or why he seems intent on frustrating the agenda.

You Might Also Be Interested In