Ex-NYPD Officer Charged in Brooklyn Jogger's Death Says Allah Told Him to Kill

Sayed Mohassib, 27, said in a published interview on Nov. 21 that he killed Katie Suarez, a 28-year-old jogger, because Allah had ordered it. He spoke at Rikers Island, where he is being held. "Allah told me to kill a person, so I killed her, the jogger Katie Suarez," he said. "I didn't know her, she was just there." He said the order came two days before the Oct. 30 attack: "Two days before it happened, Allah told me I had to kill a person."
That account conflicts with the criminal complaint filed after his arrest, which says he told detectives he took a knife to the Shore Parkway Greenway because he believed "people were going to come and kill his family," denied stabbing anyone, and said that, on a bench, he "became covered in blood." In the interview he said he had first denied the killing. "At first I said that I didn't do it, but now I'm saying that I did it because Allah told me to." He added, "I got home from work, I got the knife, and I killed her."
Suarez, who worked at a bank, suffered several knife wounds to the neck on a Brooklyn greenway at Bay 17th Street, along Shore Parkway, the New York Police Department said. Her father found her. She died Nov. 2. Detectives arrested Mohassib on Nov. 7. The complaint accuses him of second-degree murder, plus tampering with physical evidence and a fourth-degree weapon count. It cites surveillance video of a man identified as Mohassib approaching the path before the assault and fleeing afterward. The same footage, the complaint says, shows him arriving home and coming back outside about a quarter hour later, in underwear, to drop items down a trash chute. A reddish mark on an apartment wall was identified as blood, the complaint says.
A judge ordered him held without bail, he pleaded not guilty, and on Nov. 10 a Brooklyn grand jury indicted him, with second-degree murder as the lead charge, District Attorney Eric Gonzalez said. "We will vigorously prosecute this case to seek the full accountability that justice demands," Gonzalez said. His lawyer, Edward Mandery, waived Mohassib's appearance that day and asked that protective custody continue.
City payroll records show Mohassib began Police Academy training in April 2022, and a department spokesman said his first assignment after graduation was Oct. 18, 2022. On Nov. 28, the department said, it placed him on military and extended leave, barely a month into active duty. Officials said the department took the firearm issued to him and did not restore it. He submitted a resignation on Dec. 16, 2022, while still on that leave, which the department confirmed as his separation date.
The Marine Corps has said his last duty assignment was Dec. 15, 2022, and that he was discharged after serving less than a month. In a statement, the Marines said his "premature discharge is indicative that his service was incongruent with Marine Corps' expectations and standards." Law enforcement sources and local elected officials have tied the discharge to psychiatric grounds.
On Jan. 11, 2023, he asked to be reinstated, a police spokesman said, and the department said, "Several supervisors observed that he exhibited concerning behavior and appeared disheveled. That same day, he was transported to Bellevue Hospital. He was never reinstated to the NYPD."
Law enforcement officials said that on Sept. 27, 2024, his mother and sister told a 911 operator he had threatened to "chop them up." The same officials said officers found him later that day and took him to Coney Island Hospital. In a joint statement, Council Member Kayla Santosuosso, Assembly Member-elect Chris McCreight and Sen. Andrew Gounardes described him as "evidently a mentally disturbed man with no criminal record" and said he had been "discharged from the military on psychiatric grounds."
Payroll records show the Department of Education first paid him as a school aide in 2019 and, by 2024, as a paraprofessional for P.S. 200, Bath Beach. Law enforcement officials said he kept reporting there until his arrest. The education department suspended him and later fired him. Mayor Zohran Mamdani ordered a review of city hiring. On Nov. 13, Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels asked the Law Department for an independent review of how applicants are screened, how city agencies share records, and what protections apply after someone is hired.
State Sen. Stephen Chan said staff are preparing a bill that would "mandate psychological evaluations for paraprofessionals as well as school aides and perhaps even substitutes in these schools."
Mohassib remains in custody after pleading not guilty, and the hiring review the mayor and the chancellor ordered is underway.
You Might Also Be Interested In

Eight Killed in Brooklyn Collapse; Records Show Sign Penalties on Fallen Building

Long Island Should Keep Gas Available for New Homes Ahead of a Projected Statewide Power Shortfall

Mamdani Asks Council to Push Rikers Closure Back Five Years, to End of 2032


