The South Shore Press
← Back to State
State

Long Island Should Keep Gas Available for New Homes Ahead of a Projected Statewide Power Shortfall

The grid operator now projects New York's first supply deficiency in 2033 as winter heating demand rises, and Long Island's margin rests on a single transmission project due in 2030

By Howard Roark
Long Island Should Keep Gas Available for New Homes Ahead of a Projected Statewide Power Shortfall
The four smokestacks of the Northport Power Station stand along Long Island Sound in Northport, New York, in a file photograph from December 28, 2007.Credit: Fmtownsmarty / Wikimedia Commons (public domain)

Rep. Nick Langworthy posted on Nov. 19 that "This is a five-alarm warning for Governor Hochul and every Democrat legislator in Albany that their dangerous, reckless push to full electrification will have catastrophic consequences if allowed to go forward." He was reacting to a reliability study by New York's Independent System Operator, which said it had identified the first statewide supply shortfall in its assessments. The report supports a narrower claim than his, and that narrower claim is still enough to argue against forcing homes off natural gas.

The 2026 Reliability Needs Assessment finds that supply falls short of demand by about 225 megawatts in 2033 and by more than 1,850 megawatts in 2036. The operator ties the gap mainly to about 2,700 megawatts of large loads, including 1,700 megawatts of data centers and 1,000 megawatts of industrial plants, and to an aging fleet. About 4,600 megawatts of fossil plants now on the system will be older than 70 years by 2036, and the report treats about 2,600 megawatts as unavailable by then, nearly all of it in New York City and on Long Island. Emergency actions, used about 3.5 days a year in 2027, are projected to reach about 21 days a year by 2036, and the report says 2026 has already exceeded the 3.5-day mark.

Electrification enters the assessment through winter, when the report says conditions account for about 40 percent of annual lost-load risk by 2036, driven by rising demand for building heat and fuel limits on power plants. On the coldest days the gas network is fully used for firm demand such as home heating, and the report assumes about 5,400 megawatts of generation without firm gas contracts, mostly in eastern New York, is unavailable at winter peak. An informational case that adds faster heating and vehicle electrification, more retirements and more clean generation still leaves a 3,300-megawatt statewide shortfall in 2036, well above the base case. The report does not treat that case as a finding of need.

The report finds Long Island's summer and winter margins sufficient through the ten-year study window, though the early-year cushion is thin, and says the Island would be short as early as summer 2030 without the Propel NY transmission project, starting at 30 megawatts and growing to 750 megawatts by summer 2036. Propel NY is due in service in May 2030. A delay in that single project would remove the cushion.

The operator's 2026 load forecast puts Long Island's winter peak at 3,281 megawatts in 2026-27 and 4,173 megawatts in 2036-37, a rise of 892 megawatts, or 27 percent, while the summer peak grows about 7 percent over the same decade. The winter forecast includes 460 megawatts of building electrification by 2036-37, and the forecast states that none of its projections assume New York will hit its own electrification targets. Moving more Long Island homes onto electric heat pumps would push that number higher.

LIPA's 2026 budget lowers the typical residential bill by $6.53, or 3.3 percent, and sets aside $1 billion a year for grid work. National Grid serves about 600,000 gas accounts on the Island and the Rockaway Peninsula, and each customer who is moved off gas and onto the electric system adds winter load in the season when the grid operator says lost-load risk is rising.

The state's All-Electric Buildings Act, which requires all-electric systems in new buildings of seven stories or fewer, remains on hold. Challengers filed a petition at the U.S. Supreme Court on Nov. 13, docket 26-648. Under a court-ordered stipulation with the state, the rules stay suspended until 120 days after the Court denies the petition, or, if the Court takes the case, 120 days after it sends down its judgment. Langworthy wants Gov. Kathy Hochul to suspend the law permanently and repeal it. His Energy Choice Act, which would bar state and local governments from restricting energy services by source, has 157 bipartisan co-sponsors.

The grid operator, in releasing the report, said meeting the needs would require a full mix of new and repowered plants, storage, demand cuts, flexible large loads and more transmission. A policy that limits one major energy source for new homes while the grid is short of supply sits at odds with that mix, and Long Island's margin already depends on one transmission project coming in on time as its winter peak is forecast to climb 27 percent. Albany can keep gas available for new construction until the supply side catches up, and Suffolk's ratepayers, who will carry more of that winter load if homes leave the gas system, are in a position to ask it to.

You Might Also Be Interested In