The South Shore Press
← Back to State
State

Calls for R State Chair Cox to Step Aside. Jesse Garcia is the Man For the Job.

Terrible Election Results. A Defunct State Party. The Solution is Suffolk County's Own Jesse Garcia.

By The South Shore Press Editorial Board
Calls for R State Chair Cox to Step Aside. Jesse Garcia is the Man For the Job.
Jesse Garcia, chairman of the Suffolk County Republican Committee, in an official photograph from the committee.Credit: Photo courtesy of the Suffolk County Republican Committee

Chairman Ed Cox still leads New York's Republican State Committee, and he has said he is not leaving. After disastrous November results that left Republicans with little to show statewide, the calls for him to step aside have grown.

We respect Ed Cox. His long and distinguished career in politics is admirable, but the state of New York is in peril and the stakes are simply too high for him to continue as party leader. It is time for a change, and this newspaper's view is that Jesse Garcia, the Suffolk County Republican chairman, is the best and only person for that job.

The calls for change have been widespread. Anthony Constantino, from the 21st Congressional District, moved early to demand a change, writing, "Fire Ed Cox!" and that "In NYS, the Republican Party is mostly a Con Job that helps Democrats win." New York's Young Republican Club has called for Cox's removal, writing that he "lost us the Senate in 2018 and lost EVERYTHING in 2026" and that "Cox must be removed and replaced with new leadership." Stefano Forte, the club's president, has described the Cox era as over and said the party needs younger, populist leadership. David Souliere IV, chairman of the Plattsburgh city Republican committee, has been reported as calling on Cox to resign "immediately." Marc Molinaro, a former congressman now returning to the Assembly, was quoted as saying, "I don't make it personal, but there needs to be change."

Ed Cox is 80, chaired the state party from 2009 until 2019, and came back to the post in 2023. Republicans lost the state Senate in 2018, during that first tenure, and this past November Gov. Kathy Hochul defeated Bruce Blakeman statewide, with Democrats pointing toward veto-proof control of both legislative houses. Cox has said, "No. I'm not stepping down," and in a separate statement told Republicans, "This is not the time for accusations or a circular firing squad." He asked the party to "regroup, come together and develop a strategy for moving forward, building upon the foundation of the six House seats that Republicans continue to hold."

Nobody should pretend that getting Republicans elected in the state of New York is easy, or that anyone, including Jesse Garcia, could have sidestepped the beatdown the party took this month. Republican voters are angry at the administration in Washington, and they took that out on down ballot races across the country. But the history of the state party prior to 2026 shows that work needs to be done if we are ever going to pry back control from a group of people who seem determined to destroy New York.

If you look around the country you will find Republican state parties that are good and bad, delivering all kinds of results. Like a sports team, culture matters, and like a sports team the phrase is often "winning is culture," meaning that winning begets more winning, and losing begets more losing. Success raises the bar, establishes new standards, reinforces good habits, and shames those who don't live up to that bar. Our beloved Yankees have learned a thing or two about this in the last 30 years. In red states you find Republican party leadership that is energized, actively engaged in candidate recruitment in every down ballot race, holding routine events for the base who is likewise energized, and that energy manifests as door knockers who turn out the vote on election day. Winning begets winning. The opposite is also true in blue states. In places like California, Illinois and New York, nobody expects to win. That is true as much for party leadership as it is for the average voter deciding whether to go cast a vote on election day. It requires a substantial effort for anyone in leadership to get that guy to drive to a polling station to wait in line to vote in an election doomed to fail. Imagine trying to get that same guy to show up to the local pizza night and give $20 to support the local candidates on a random Tuesday in July, or even worse, put his life on hold to go run for a political office he believes he can never win. Losing begets losing.

It is a tough effort to turn a political aircraft carrier around in a place like New York. It starts with a grass roots effort, in every town and in every local race around the state in places where nobody believes we can win and it isn't worth their time to get involved. This is precisely why Jesse Garcia is the right man for the job.

The core of the case for Garcia is the method he has used to run the Suffolk County Republican Committee. He leads, by our estimation, one of the most effective political apparatuses in the nation. He and his team have recruited and hand-selected candidates and staff for every office and race for every lever of power across the county. Those levers of power are used to keep the base informed and engaged, and to keep that energy high in the ordinary months as well as in campaign season. Importantly, this includes engaging young voters to be involved in the process as staff, as digital media contributors and even as candidates. That is how a county party keeps itself in fighting shape, and it is the apparatus this newspaper believes he should be given the chance to replicate across the state.

The "every race" on the ballot matters, treating the whole ticket as the work, and in election years this "every race" approach generates a massive mobilization force to drive out the vote. Statewide there are hundreds of races each year that go "uncontested," meaning the Republican party simply does not offer a candidate. These occur in Democrat strongholds where there is little prospect of Republican victory, but that absence of a candidate trickles across the ballot as that is one less candidate knocking doors, sending emails and hosting events, resulting in a statewide cascade of R turnout issues. One piece of political irony is that if we are ever to take back power from the Democrats, it starts with voter turnout in places where we cannot win. Those votes add up.

There is no denying the results Garcia has had running the ship in Suffolk. He was first elected county chairman in April 2019 and was chosen again in September 2025, the fifth time the county committee selected him. Under that tenure Republicans have taken the district attorney's office, won the county executive's office, held a majority in the county legislature, and narrowed a long Democratic lead in voter enrollment. This past November Suffolk's Republican House incumbents held their seats in a year that went badly for the party across the state.

Other names have been floated for the job. This newspaper likes Rep. Nicole Malliotakis and outgoing Rep. Elise Stefanik, and welcomes their continued involvement in state politics. They are smart, capable and leaders in their own lanes. The role of state chair, however, is that of a mechanic. Someone who knows how the machine works, which tools to use, and how to use them. Garcia has toiled in that role already with a clear track record of success.

Jesse Garcia has been no friend to the South Shore Press. We have no working relationship with Mr. Garcia or many of his team for reasons that have been documented elsewhere and are the unfortunate consequence of the politics of politics. But objectively we cannot deny the job Garcia has done on behalf of Republicans in Suffolk County and thereby, in this newspaper's opinion, on behalf of our readers and the working families in our community. We are often asked by people for our opinion on Garcia and our answer is consistent: politics is a nasty business that requires tough people to do tough things if you have any hope of winning, and there is no better man for the job that we have seen than Garcia. That has been unambiguously true in Suffolk County, and it is time we applied that same force across the state.

As President Trump once famously said, "What the hell do you have to lose?" As Republicans in the state of New York, that statement applies, and the stakes could not be higher. Garcia must be given the opportunity to replicate his Suffolk apparatus across the state and see what he can do. Worst case, he fails and we are right back where we all believe we are today. Best case, he does what we think he can do, we break super majorities in Albany, and start bringing some sanity back to the place we all love and call home. That is a bet we should all want to take.

This newspaper respectfully asks that Cox step aside and that Garcia be given a shot. No malice. No ego. We love the state and desperately want to see change. It is a long road ahead, and Garcia is the guy who can lead us down it.

You Might Also Be Interested In